Skip to main content

Red-Eye Special: Bowhunting Florida Gators

Red-Eye Special: Bowhunting Florida Gators

The night life on Florida's aquatic boardwalks can get downright dangerous when you're bowhunting gators.


We chased countless gators before I had my first shooting opportunity.





No more than 15 minutes after we launched the 18-foot johnboat, an alligator's red eyes flashed in the beam of our high-powered spotlight. Then, as suddenly as the gator's eyes appeared, they vanished into the night.

Our gator hunt had started at sunset, and as we'd done dozens of other times that night, we continued on across the lake in search of more red eyes. Finally, after hours of spotlighting, we came within 30 yards of a gator. Once again the gator submerged, and another attempt failed. My preconceived notions of simply floating up to an alligator and shooting him for an easy kill were quickly sinking with these gators.


Cameraman Don Belles of Spiritual Outdoor Adventures and I were hunting with TNT Gators, a licensed nuisance alligator company located just west of Tallahassee, Florida. Owners Tony Hun-ter and Tiger Godwin have a combined 35 years of alligator experience.

Alligator hunters, or trappers, as Florida classifies them, have four one-week seasons, running from mid-August through the morning of November 1. Each hunter is limited to two gators per permit. If a hunter does not use all of his tags, he must return them to the state. The tags are not transferable. All hunters are advised to attend an alligator training course, provided free of charge throughout the state prior to the opener.

When planning my gator hunt, I learned that hunters with an outfitter/ guide are required by law to kill a gator prior to bringing it into the boat, and to do this they often use a device called a bang stick. Aimed behind the gator's skullcap and angled toward the brain, a bang stick discharges a firearm cartridge.

This option didn't really appeal to me. I'm a guy who likes to jump on just about any critter, so capturing an alligator alive seemed much more exciting.

Through research, I found 38 nuisance alligator trappers licensed through the state, including TNT Gators. A nuisance alligator is defined by state law as one measuring four feet in length and posing a threat to people, pets, or property. Nuisance alligator trappers, who remove these "pests" from neighborhoods, garages, backyards, and swimming pools, can capture them alive. Better yet, their season runs 365 days a year. Perfect.

For ammunition, I used the Muzzy Gator Getter system. It's similar to Muzzy's setup for gar and carp, with one exception -- is a float or buoy attached to the line. Once the Muzzy fish point hits the gator, the 500-pound test restraining line and float go out with the main line. You then use the line to pull the gator to the boat.

Tony's son, Mike, and Tiger were amazing at spotting those eerie, red gator eyes. Collectively, Don and I probably saw only half of the gators Tiger and Mike spotted. In addition, they could estimate a gator's size with a quick look. Mike explained that every inch between the eye sockets and the tip of the nose roughly equates to one foot in total body length.

Upon hatching, baby alligators are only nine inches long. Here I'm holding a two-year-old gator we captured by hand from the side of the johnboat.

Finally, near 4:30 a.m., we located tell-tale red eyes that didn't submerge at our approach.

"C.J., get ready!" Tiger whispered. Trust me, I was! Trouble was, the gator kept swimming a little faster than our boat, and shooting a 1,900-grain arrow out of my 70-pound bow, I was not confident in taking a 25-yard shot. We needed to get closer. Eventually the gator slowed, and I released my Muzzy fiberglass arrow. Upon impact, the string and float flew off my bow as if I'd harpooned Moby Dick.

The gator plunged some 20 yards and stopped, and that's when the real action began. Recovering the float attached to the line was critical to prevent the line and float from tangling in underwater debris. If the float got stuck under water, retrieving the gator would be difficult, if not impossible. Knowing this, Tiger cranked up the outboard motor and raced to overtake the float.

Following Tiger's directions, I grabbed the float and started pulling in the line attached to the gator. At first, it was easy because I was simply pulling in slack, but then the line tightened directly from me to the critter, and I€ˆfelt like I€ˆwas pulling in a runaway truck with a kite string.

And this critter wasn't giving up. Every time we got close, he took off on another powerful run. After 15 minutes of this game, the gator went under the boat, and I thought we finally had him.

Wrong! Off he went again, and as we watched the float fly out of the boat and skim across the water, I clinched my teeth and determined this was his last run. We would get him alongside the boat this time.

For added leverage, and to prevent further rope burns -- I'd forgot to put on my gloves -- I wrapped the string around my hand. As soon as Tiger saw this, he yelled, "Stop!" but it was too late, and the gator took off with my hand attached to the line. Luckily, Mike grabbed the line and created enough slack for me to free my hand. His quick move prevented the gator from dragging me into the water!

After more back-and-forth, I finally wore the gator out and pulled him next to the johnboat, where Tiger put a noose around the gator's neck. With water flying everywhere, the gator did the characteristic death roll and chomped the side of the boat. When he finally calmed down, Tiger pressed his jaws together and had me tape the gator's mouth shut with electrical tape. We then taped the legs together and wrestled the monster into the boat, where we measured him at 8 feet, 8 inches long and estimated his weight at 250 pounds.

The next night, Don and I switched roles -- I would shoot the camera, he would shoot the bow. Since it took us over seven long hours to tag mine, we didn't expect to have much luck until the wee hours of the morning, but by midnight Tiger had us on the tail of giant. For 15 minutes we followed the critter across the lake and back again, and when it never submerged, Tiger decided to try swinging ahead to cut it off. This strategy worked, and Don's arrow found its mark directly behind the alligator's neck.

Don Belles, C.J. Winand, Mike Hunter and Tiger Godwin all proudly pose with the two gators they hunted. Gator meat is delicious and runs around $7 — $10 per pound.

The look on Don's face was priceless, and watching him strain against the line was like a case of bad déjà vu. Only this time, I could laugh at Don as he wrestled his big gator into the boat. Once we got the reptile on board, Tiger measured it at 9 feet, 4 inches in length. Determining its gender, Tiger said, "Don, this is one of the largest females we've ever captured. In fact, very few females ever get over nine feet." We later found out that Don's 400-pound female gator was only 10 inches shy of the all-time state record.

Although Don's gator was fully re-strained with electrical tape in the boat, she was still very much alive. As Don was watching the video I'd shot of him, the gator moved her large tail. The girly sound that came out of Don's mouth was something we would just as soon forget.

Gator hunting is filled with excitement that produces a pile of great eating meat. In my mind, every bowhunter should experience this unique challenge. The good folks at TNT Gators were simply the best, and I can't wait to get back out there with Tiger and Mike next May to search for red eyes. It's pretty special.

Author's Notes: Both Don and I used Mathews bows; Muzzy Gator Getter System arrows, points, and floats; and Carter thumb release aids.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

New for 2021: Bear Redemption EKO, Legit RTH Compound Bows

New for 2021: Bear Redemption EKO, Legit RTH Compound Bows

Bear Archery's newest bows - Redemption EKO and Legit RTH - are light, adjustable and fast.

Better Bow Accuracy: Release Arm Alignment

Better Bow Accuracy: Release Arm Alignment

On this edition of "Dead On," pro archer Randy Ulmer shows you how to properly align your release arm for better accuracy and bowhunting practice.

Canyon Ranch Roundup Part 1

Canyon Ranch Roundup Part 1

Bowhunter TV's Derek Mleynek and Equipment Editor Tony J. Peterson head to Texas for a late-season mixed bag hunt that promises plenty of action.

Canyon Ranch Roundup Part 2

Canyon Ranch Roundup Part 2

Bowhunter TV's Derek Mleynek and Equipment Editor Tony J. Peterson head to Texas for a late-season mixed bag hunt in a truly target-rich environment.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Sometimes, it's a mistake to give deer too much credit for thinking.Can Whitetails Reason? Whitetail

Can Whitetails Reason?

Gene Wensel

Sometimes, it's a mistake to give deer too much credit for thinking.

The biggest day of the new year for bowhunters is here. Here's your first look at the latest batch of hunting rigs.New Hunting Bows for 2021 ATA Show

New Hunting Bows for 2021

Tony J. Peterson - January 13, 2021

The biggest day of the new year for bowhunters is here. Here's your first look at the latest...

Bowhunter Editor Curt Wells had an exciting visit with Mark Hayes, design engineer for Mathews, as the pair looked at the new V3 27 and V3 31 bows.New for 2021: Mathews V3 27 & 31 Bows ATA Show

New for 2021: Mathews V3 27 & 31 Bows

Bowhunter Staff - January 20, 2021

Bowhunter Editor Curt Wells had an exciting visit with Mark Hayes, design engineer for...

Inspired by “Buzzwinkle,” a lit up moose in Anchorage, this Apple and Cheddar-Ale Moose Burger Recipe is sure to be a delicious party on your taste buds with every bite.Apple and Cheddar-Ale Moose Burger Recipe Recipes

Apple and Cheddar-Ale Moose Burger Recipe

Jenny Nguyen-Wheatley

Inspired by “Buzzwinkle,” a lit up moose in Anchorage, this Apple and Cheddar-Ale Moose Burger...

See More Trending Articles

More North America

As bowhunters, we're enamored with the tough hunts. If it doesn't nearly kill you to get close toBowhunting in Texas Provides Off-Season Fun North America

Bowhunting in Texas Provides Off-Season Fun

Tony J. Peterson - December 19, 2016

As bowhunters, we're enamored with the tough hunts. If it doesn't nearly kill you to get close...

Q: My hunting partner and I really want to expand our horizons and do a DIY out-of-state bowhuntAsk Bowhunter: Setting Up an Out-of-State Hunting Trip North America

Ask Bowhunter: Setting Up an Out-of-State Hunting Trip

Tony J. Peterson

Q: My hunting partner and I really want to expand our horizons and do a DIY out-of-state...

If you're ready to branch out a bit to hunt whitetails, there are tools to help you along the way. Choosing a New State or Area to Hunt North America

Choosing a New State or Area to Hunt

Matt Palmquist

If you're ready to branch out a bit to hunt whitetails, there are tools to help you along the...

Anybody who knows me knows I'm a deer nut (Bowhunter Magazine's Mexico Mule Deer Dreams North America

Mexico Mule Deer Dreams

C. J. Winand - April 04, 2018

Anybody who knows me knows I'm a deer nut (Bowhunter Magazine's "Hunting Whitetails"...

See More North America

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Bowhunter App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Bowhunter subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now