Skip to main content

CWD Affects Antler Restrictions

It seems that at least once a year I devote some column space to chronic wasting disease, and the reason is that it is the most important negative factor that our hunting future has ever faced. Yes, the negative potential of CWD is that bad.

This young whitetail buck is stricken with chronic wasting disease. The question is, will the lifting of antler restrictions in states like Missouri and Arkansas help slow the spread of this insidious disease in those states?

CWD is now found in 24 states, three Canadian provinces, plus Norway and South Korea. Make no mistake about it, this spread will continue. Over the next 12 months, more areas will get CWD. Missouri first got CWD in 2010 when it was detected on a game farm. They'd been watching for it for years. Missouri tested 22,000 deer from the wild from 2002 to 2004. From 2007-2011 they tested 16,000 deer. In 2010, they found CWD in a deer from a game farm. Two more were found from a shooting preserve 15 miles from that farm in 2011.

It was only a matter of time before it would jump from those captive deer to the wild. Sure enough, CWD was found in two free-range deer close to the deer farm in January 2012. The DNR immediately removed 650 deer within five miles of the farm, and five were positive. The 2012-2013 winter killed a number of deer and four were positive, plus another during the fall hunting season.


Others were found up to 2014, and all within two adjacent Northeast Missouri counties. However, in the 2014 fall hunting season, a huge buck from a central-Missouri county tested positive. This prompted the game agency to eliminate antler restrictions in the 29 counties around infected counties.


Why would they do that when hunters really supported antler restrictions? The answer is simple: A large majority of yearling bucks disperse up to 12 miles in the spring or fall. Such dispersal of a CWD-positive buck spreads the disease. Thus, eliminating antler restrictions is a strategy to slow that spread. I discussed hunter reaction to the elimination of antler restrictions with a game agency official, and he noted that there was a surprisingly low amount of negative reaction. They apparently understood the gravity of the problem.

Missouri is not the only state to use this strategy. Antler restrictions have been in place in Arkansas since 1998, but CWD was first found in deer in 2015. This prompted the sampling of 166 deer around the area where the positive deer was harvested, and 23 percent tested positive. Obviously, CWD had been there quite a while. This prompted the removal of antler restrictions in a 10-county area. Can we expect to see this strategy used as CWD continues to spread? Probably. Just another negative outgrowth of CWD.

Bad Winter Affecting Wildlife In The West

This past February 3, Utah closed shed hunting until April. The reason was simple. Deep snows affected the ability of deer, elk, and moose to find food. Any further disturbance from shed hunters would put more stress on the animals, and exacerbate the situation. Apparently some people enjoy shed hunting a great deal, maybe too much, and within two weeks of the ban over 16 were arrested.


The deep snows this past winter also led to another rarely used strategy. Normally, the feeding of deer and elk is a bad idea. However, deep snows in the West changed that this past winter. Idaho started a feeding program in the southern part of the state, and Oregon did so in the eastern portion of that state. Without feeding, deer losses would have been much worse.

Baiting Bill In Alabama

The present baiting regulation in Alabama requires hunters to place bait at least 100 yards from any stand, and not in the line of sight of any stand. This regulation applies to hog and deer hunting on private land. However, as I write this column in March, there is a bill that just passed the House and is going to the Alabama Senate for a vote. This bill allows baiting on private land, but eliminates the 100-yard and line-of-sight ban. But there is an interesting twist.


The bill mandates that hunters must buy a $15 license to bait. This bait license is in addition to their regular hunting license, and if passed, it is expected to bring in an additional $1.5 million.

If this bill passes, will we see other state game agencies implement such a "bait license?" Most state wildlife agencies are short on money, and baiting is extremely popular with hunters. Will the hunters be willing to pay to bait? My guess is that if passed in Alabama, we will see other states move to this strategy.

Mountain Lions Kill Moose

In recent years there has been a great deal of interest in predators killing deer, elk, and moose. Just how much do they take? Researchers at the University of Alberta have given us some answers. They followed collared cougars, and also did ground searches, to locate an amazing 1,509 "predator events." As part of this study, they followed 42 GPS-collared lions for a combined total of 9,543 days. That alone is rather amazing.

Captured cougars included 30 adult females, seven adult males, six subadult females, and 10 subadult males (Note: not all lions were collared). Kill rates for deer, elk, and moose were an average of 0.8 animals per week, but there was a lot of variability. In fact, one cougar went 75 days without killing an ungulate, apparently surviving on small birds, mammals, or carrion.

Cougars killed 1.49 times as many ungulates in the summer as in the winter, as more young prey were taken. Average searching time before killing an ungulate was lower in summer (117 hours) than winter (159 hrs). Females with kittens killed most often. Here are the interesting numbers.

The average number of ungulates killed per year was 67 for females with kittens more than six months of age, 47 for females with kittens less than six months of age, 42 for adult females without kittens, 35 for adult males, 31 for subadult males, and 24 for subadult females. The fact that adult males killed fewer animals than adult females was attributed to the fact that they killed larger prey. The researchers also noted that cougars rarely killed adult moose, but they did take juvenile moose.

Now Alberta officials have some idea of how many big game animals are taken by mountain lions and can better assess harvest strategies in various parts of the province. Great data to have, and it sheds some light on the impacts of mountain lion predation.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Tree Saddle Hunting: Best Platforms & Ring of Steps

Tree Saddle Hunting: Best Platforms & Ring of Steps

We all need a spot to place our feet in life … and even more so when in the saddle. The two options are a platform or ring-of-steps. For longer hunts, platforms are more comfortable and most familiar. Ring-of-steps are lighter and easier to pack for shorter-duration hunts and long hikes.

Better Bow Practice: Pick a Spot When Aiming

Better Bow Practice: Pick a Spot When Aiming

On this edition of "Dead On," Hall-of-Fame bowhunter Randy Ulmer shares advice on picking a spot to aim at when practicing with your bow.

Tree Saddle Hunting: Best Tree-Climbing Sticks

Tree Saddle Hunting: Best Tree-Climbing Sticks

Sectional sticks are the most popular tree-climbing method among saddle enthusiasts because sticks are safe, effective, easy to use, and you only have to hang three or four of them to reach heights of 17-22 feet if you add a lightweight climbing aider.

Tree Saddle Hunting: Best New Climbing-Stick Attachment Options

Tree Saddle Hunting: Best New Climbing-Stick Attachment Options

The array of ultra-strong, easy-to-use, light and quiet aftermarket stick attachment options has never been more creative and compelling. The noisier, heavier, harder-to-conveniently-wrap-on-your-sticks metal buckle and strap is anathema for today's mobile hunter.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Is FOC really all it's cracked up to be? Is it important to accuracy and penetration?Arrow FOC: Why It's Important for Bowhunting Arrows & Broadheads

Arrow FOC: Why It's Important for Bowhunting

Jace Bauserman

Is FOC really all it's cracked up to be? Is it important to accuracy and penetration?

Sometimes, it's a mistake to give deer too much credit for thinking.Can Whitetails Reason? Whitetail

Can Whitetails Reason?

Gene Wensel

Sometimes, it's a mistake to give deer too much credit for thinking.

New tree saddles, platforms, sticks and more provide greater efficiency and enjoyment when tree saddle hunting.Tree Saddle Hunting Gear Round-Up - Best of the Best Treestands & Blinds

Tree Saddle Hunting Gear Round-Up - Best of the Best

Mike Carney - November 23, 2020

New tree saddles, platforms, sticks and more provide greater efficiency and enjoyment when...

As a bowhunter, you need complete faith in your physical ability to hike in to your hunting ground, stalk your prey, pull your bow stealthily and pack out your animal. That means it's essential to train for your hunt.10 Workout Routines Every Bowhunter Should Master How-To

10 Workout Routines Every Bowhunter Should Master

Adam Holt

As a bowhunter, you need complete faith in your physical ability to hike in to your hunting...

See More Trending Articles

More Conservation

Taking long-distance shots at big-game animals has become acceptable, but here's why it isn't the ethical choice.Is it Ethical to Take Long-Distance Bowhunting Shots? Conservation

Is it Ethical to Take Long-Distance Bowhunting Shots?

Curt Wells

Taking long-distance shots at big-game animals has become acceptable, but here's why it isn't...

To get the most out of modern hunting, learn to use this valuable hunting tool -- the Internet.Instant Answers Conservation

Instant Answers

Dr. Dave Samuel - November 04, 2010

To get the most out of modern hunting, learn to use this valuable hunting tool -- the Internet.

Lead fragments in meat threaten some venison donation programs.Get The Lead Out Conservation

Get The Lead Out

Dr. Dave Samuel - November 04, 2010

Lead fragments in meat threaten some venison donation programs.



For years, one of the arguments the antis used in their tirades against hunting was the idea thatTrophy Talk: Does Hunting Hurt Horn & Antler Growth? Conservation

Trophy Talk: Does Hunting Hurt Horn & Antler Growth?

Dr. Dave Samuel - July 02, 2013

For years, one of the arguments the antis used in their tirades against hunting was the idea...

See More Conservation

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Bowhunter App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Bowhunter subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now