Nonresident Bowhunter Hate

Are we our own worst enemies when it comes to the trend of diminishing hunter numbers?

Nonresident Bowhunter Hate

The looks I get when I bowhunt South Dakota's public land are impressive. For a lot of the folks I run across, they don't even try to hide their disgust that someone from Minnesota is hunting their deer. The mean-mugging is rampant, and the hostility is sometimes very thinly veiled.

I've seen the contempt in other states as well and have been on the other side of it. When I was growing up, we fished Pool 4 on the Mississippi River quite a bit. The fisherman who always seemed to disregard our personal space and try to fish right on top of us were from Iowa. We hated them. Then I started going up to northern Minnesota to fish, and it was the rich resort-goers with their ski boats from Illinois who drew our ire.

At that time, I didn't need anything Iowa or Illinois had to offer, so I'd have gladly turned them both around at the state line. Later in high school, however, I started traveling to Iowa to pheasant hunt. They had roosters to spare, and in southern Minnesota, we didn't. At least not as many. What they didn't have was water. Where we have lakes and rivers everywhere, they had ag fields and CRP fields. It dawned on me that trading some walleyes for some roosters wasn't that bad of a deal.

That was in the 90s, of course, long before Iowa looked west and decided that if it's cool to screw nonresident big game hunters with exorbitant license fees in the mountain states, they could too. After all, they have the big deer.


What's The Problem?

I've written plenty on how the gouging of nonresidents will be a net loss for hunters and conservation dollars over time, so I won't go there again. I don't blame states for doing it because it's legal and they can get away with it. Eventually, however, they'll have to figure out a new game-management revenue source because we'll lose hunters to the point where the demand isn't what it used to be, and contrary to the current trend, there isn't total inelasticity when it comes to the price someone will pay to shoot a deer or an elk.


What I do blame for this issue is us – the hunters. I run into hate for nonresidents so often that it's easy to see why we condone charging out-of-state hunters 30 times what we pay to hunt the same animals. After all, those hunters might be making it three percent harder for us to hunt, or they might have access to land we don't have. They deserve to be punished, right?

It's easy – and common – for residents of a state to hate nonresident bowhunters, but that attitude is short-sighted and does all of us a disservice.

And we all know it's the nonresidents who are the law-breakers and the lazy road hunters. They shoot all of the forkies too, so that none of the bucks can reach maturity. They are a loathsome lot. They really are.

If you can't tell yet, I'm being facetious. I've heard every nasty thing that can be said about nonresidents, and it would be laughable if it wasn't so common. I've probably hunted close to 20 states in my life, much of it on public land while bumping elbows with residents and nonresidents alike, and my honest opinion is that a decent percentage of hunters are just lazy.


That laziness doesn't breed hunting success, but most of us would never admit why we don't punch our tags very often. There must be some outside reason, and that reason just might be the hunters who reside across some arbitrary lines on the map. At least that's as good of an excuse as any.

The Real Problem

There have been a pile of articles written lately on the loss of hunters. Bowhunters haven't felt it quite as much yet, but we will. It's coming, and stopping it won't be easy if it's even possible at all. The older generation is giving up, and no one is coming in to fill their spots.

We have fewer people paying for conservation, and none of us wins from that. None of us wins when our collective voice is weakened either. We are at a whisper now, just wait another decade or two to see if anyone at all will listen to us. They might, but then again, they might not. Access is an issue too, and not a small one. Most of us have fewer places to hunt than we did not long ago. That trend is going to continue, and it doesn't bodewell for our numbers.


Hunting out-of-state is getting more expensive and opportunities are more limited than ever, which will eventually dissuade more and more bowhunters from traveling.

I don't know what to do about either issue, although I've got some ideas. What I do know is that we could remedy our propensity to punish one another because of where we live.

My Fellow Hunters

I know that there are plenty of bowhunters who will read this and get angry. They'll say, "Where I hunt is overrun with nonresidents, and the woods could stand to clear out some!" Sure, everyone has anecdotal evidence of too many hunters in the woods. I spend half of my fall on public land, I get it.

But before you fire off angry emails or leave comments that I'll never read, do this one thing - when you're justifying gouging nonresidents for their licenses or advocating to severely limit their opportunity, replace "nonresidents" with "my fellow hunters." Try it just once to see how it sounds.

Because those folks that you're willing to gouge, they are a revenue source just as you are, and their voice is needed just as much as you are. They buy hunting gear, and maybe they introduce a few youngsters to the sport you love. They are like you, whether you'll admit it or not, and if they go away eventually you will too. And if not you, your children or grandchildren. The karma might not prove instant, but it will happen.

When it does, it will be nobody's fault but our own.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

2018 Bowhunter TV Episode 12: Deer Slam!

2018 Bowhunter TV Episode 12: Deer Slam!

Bowhunter Magazine Editor Curt Wells lives his life-long dream of taking all five species of North American deer.

Turkey Decoy Beatdown

Turkey Decoy Beatdown

Bowhunter contributor Matt Palmquist witnesses a hen trying to destroy one of his decoys while hunting turkeys in Kansas.

Season Opener: Kentucky Whitetail Bowhunt

Season Opener: Kentucky Whitetail Bowhunt

Christian Berg arrives at Whitetail Heaven Outfitters in Kentucky to kick off the beginning of his hunting season.

Mountain Caribou Hunt

Mountain Caribou Hunt

Curt Wells can't pass up this opportunity to hunt mountain caribou in the Northwest Territories.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Advances in rangefinding devices have helped bowhunters immensely. Scouting Tools

Advancements in Rangefinder Technology Through the Years

Chuck Adams

Advances in rangefinding devices have helped bowhunters immensely.

With May comes an opportunity to re-think turkey bowhunting strategies. Turkeys

Spring Gobbler Reset: How to Bowhunt Turkeys in May

Tony J. Peterson

With May comes an opportunity to re-think turkey bowhunting strategies.

Follow this advice before embarking on your first hunt! Big Game

Beginner's Guide to Bowhunting Mule Deer

Ron Niziolek

Follow this advice before embarking on your first hunt!

Curt Wells and Randy Ulmer [video] explain the importance of momentum and penetration when choosing heavy vs. light arrows for bowhunting. How-To

How to Choose the Best Hunting Arrow - Heavy vs. Light

Curt Wells

Curt Wells and Randy Ulmer [video] explain the importance of momentum and penetration when...

See More Trending Articles

More Stories

Choosing to bowhunt during gun season certainly adds an extra layer of difficult to and already Stories

Yes, You Can Bowhunt During Gun Season

Bowhunter TV - November 20, 2014

Choosing to bowhunt during gun season certainly adds an extra layer of difficult to and...

As hunters, we need to give the respect we want to receive from others. Stories

Respect for the Hunt & Other Hunters

Dwight Schuh

As hunters, we need to give the respect we want to receive from others.

Dwight Schuh explains why it's okay to be serious about bowhunting - but not too serious! Stories

Hunting for the Fun of It

Dwight Schuh

Dwight Schuh explains why it's okay to be serious about bowhunting - but not too serious!

A year has already passed since the loss of one the greatest bowhunters in history. Stories

Remembering Dwight Schuh One Year Later

Dwight Schuh - February 05, 2020

A year has already passed since the loss of one the greatest bowhunters in history.

See More Stories

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.